head head head
Home Contact RSS Feed
News   •   Features   •   Reviews   •   Podcasts   •   Contests   •   Contact Us   •   About Us
What Joss Whedon Didn’t Like About ‘The Empire Strikes Back’
The Movie God   |  

The Empire Strikes Back

The Avengers director Joss Whedon had a lengthy chat with Entertainment Weekly recently, and among the many things that they discussed, the topic of Star Wars sequel The Empire Strikes Back came up.

But instead of talking about how awesome Empire is, Whedon actually talked about what he disliked about the movie—and as an extension, all movies that do something similar.

Continue reading to see what he had to say.

When asked about the movie, Whedon said:

“Empire committed the cardinal sin of not actually ending. Which at the time I was appalled by and I still think it was a terrible idea.”

When asked more specifically if he thought The Empire Strikes Back had a bad ending, he explained:

“Well, it’s not an ending. It’s a Come Back Next Week, or in three years. And that upsets me. I go to movies expecting to have a whole experience. If I want a movie that doesn’t end I’ll go to a French movie. That’s a betrayal of trust to me. A movie has to be complete within itself, it can’t just build off the first one or play variations.”

Think what you will about this particular Star Wars opinion, but as a whole opinion, I could not agree more and I’m glad someone of Whedon’s status came out and said it.

Movies with no endings or movies that leave many more questions than answers absolutely infuriate me as a viewer for these exact reasons. I go into a movie to be told a story, not to be told most of a story and then have to interpret it my own way. Some folks dig that, and that’s fine, but if I could come up with the best possible ending for someone else’s story, I’d just make my own movies.

It’s even worse when a movie is really good, too. Bad movies are bad, and a crappy ending won’t matter much. But when a movie is really great and you’re left extremely unsatisfied, it’s a power shot to the gut. Movies like The Grey jump to mind, and the Coen Brothers have been known to do this a time or two.

The Empire Strikes Back is a little different for me because, obviously, it’s not the end. There’s more story after that. For someone seeing it in theaters and having to wait that long like Whedon, I get it, but now you can just pop in Return of the Jedi and keep the party going.

And just so it’s clear, Whedon does not dislike Empire. He considers it one of the sequels that “got it right” along with movies like The Godfather Part II. This is just an ending issue.

What are your thoughts? Do you like movies leaving you hanging or leaving some questions unanswered, or do you need to be told the full story you went in expecting to be told?

[Source: EW]

  • Midas68

    It would infuriate me if it wasn’t the best Star War film that the have made.

    Explaining everything can also be a insult to the audiences intelligence.

  • matt

    understandable if it was a stand alone movie but Lucas at that point was going to make a trilogy…that was the hook to get people excited for Return of the Jedi.

  • http://aeiouwhy.blogspot.com/ Dex

    At the time, it was just part of the ride for me. It’s part of the pulp serial influence on Lucas. Being able to debate on the playground for 3 years whether Vader really was Luke’s father, priceless.

  • http://nickleshi.blogspot.com/ Nick Leshi

    It was the cinematic cliffhanger equivalent to TV’s “Who shot J.R.?” Brilliant. Terrible when other movies make a weak attempt to do it, but Empire Strikes Back worked.

  • Sparky_The_Bard-barian

    And of course when we did come back in 1983, it wasn’t really worth it.

  • Micah Thomas

    Empire Strikes Back may be the exception to this rule. Otherwise, Joss is completely right on with his feelings on this.

  • demonstrable

    I’ve always kind of felt this way but it didn’t bother me that much since Return of the Jedi already existed when I first watched them all.

  • Duze

    Joss ought to look closer at what the story of Empire actually is about. Empire is as much Luke’s story as it is Anakin’s … as they are both driven to confront one another early in the film. Anakin by the Emperor, Luke indirectly by Obi-Wan and Yoda. That’s the textbook “call to adventure”. By the end, not only do they both accomplish that, but they learn something new as a result and take that with them, changing everything.
    While the movie does leave many open threads, the core story involving the main characters’ story goals were reached. The reason it MUST end open ended is because Luke should have waited to confront him until he was ready. But he’s a flawed character who didn’t — part of what makes this movie so great.

    By Joss’ same logic, Frodo should have destroyed the ring in Fellowship.

  • Vital Information

    A stupid complaint by a good but overrated nerd writer.

    I guess he had an issue with the first Lodr of the Rings movies, the first Hobbit movie, the first Kill Bill movie, and all of the Harry Potter movies except the last one. Also, he broke his own rule with that Thanos teaser at the end of The Avengers.

    Nothing to see here, move along.

  • Bob James

    And no one thought to remind him of exactly how his Buffy spin-off Angel ended, or rather, didn’t end? The remaining heroes standing in the rain in an alley, about to face off against a vast demon army, wounded and vastly outnumbered, and then, fade to black, roll credits? The story was continued in comic form later, but that was it for its television incarnation. Or perhaps he meant that the “there has to be an ending” preference only applies to big screen fare?

Topics: Movies, News
Previous Article
Next Article
Around the Web
Geeks of Doom on Instagram Follow Geeks of Doom on Tumblr
Geeks of Doom on YouTube Geeks of Doom on Pinterest
Geeks of Doom Email Digest Geeks of Doom RSS Feed
Check out all of our current contests listings
Check out all of our current contests listings
The Drill Down Podcast TARDISblend Podcast Skull-Face Island Movie Podcast
Get Geeks of Doom Gear on CafePress
BlendoveR   ·   Cinema Blend   ·   Collider   ·   Film School Rejects   ·   First Showing   ·   io9   ·   Latino Review   ·   Screen Rant   ·   Slashfilm   ·   The Mary Sue
2520 Clothing Company
Animated  ·  Apps  ·  Art  ·  Best-Sellers  ·  Bits of Doom  ·  Blog  ·  Blu-ray  ·  Book of Geek  ·  Books  ·  Cartoons  ·  Celebrity  ·  Charity  ·  Collectibles  ·  Comics  ·  Computers  ·  Contests  ·  Conventions  ·  Deals  ·  DIY  ·  Documentary  ·  Doom Deliveries  ·  DVDs  ·  Electronics  ·  Environment  ·  Fanatic  ·  Features  ·  Gadgets  ·  Games  ·  Gear  ·  Geek Finds  ·  Geek Girls  ·  Gift Guide  ·  Holidays  ·  Humor  ·  Interviews  ·  Movies  ·  Music  ·  News  ·  News Bytes  ·  Obit  ·  Photos  ·  Podcasts  ·  Politics  ·  Poll  ·  Press Releases  ·  Recaps  ·  Reviews  ·  Rumors  ·  Science  ·  Software  ·  Sports  ·  Technology  ·  Television  ·  Theater  ·  Theme Parks  ·  Trailers  ·  Travel  ·  Video Games  ·  Videos  ·  Web Games  ·  Week of Geek  ·  Zombie Round-Up
January 2014  ·   December 2013  ·   November 2013  ·   October 2013  ·   September 2013  ·   August 2013  ·   July 2013  ·   June 2013  ·   May 2013  ·   April 2013  ·   March 2013  ·   February 2013  ·   January 2013  ·   December 2012  ·   November 2012  ·   October 2012  ·   September 2012  ·   August 2012  ·   July 2012  ·   June 2012  ·   May 2012  ·   April 2012  ·   March 2012  ·   February 2012  ·   January 2012  ·   December 2011  ·   November 2011  ·   October 2011  ·   September 2011  ·   August 2011  ·   July 2011  ·   June 2011  ·   May 2011  ·   April 2011  ·   March 2011  ·   February 2011  ·   January 2011  ·   December 2010  ·   November 2010  ·   Octber 2010  ·   September 2010  ·   August 2010  ·   July 2010  ·   June 2010  ·   May 2010  ·   April 2010  ·   March 2010  ·   February 2010  ·   January 2010  ·   December 2009  ·   November 2009  ·   Octber 2009  ·   September 2009  ·   August 2009  ·   July 2009  ·   June 2009  ·   May 2009  ·   April 2009  ·   March 2009  ·   February 2009  ·   January 2009  ·   December 2008  ·   November 2008  ·   Octber 2008  ·   September 2008  ·   August 2008  ·   July 2008  ·   June 2008  ·   May 2008  ·   April 2008  ·   March 2008  ·   February 2008  ·   January 2008  ·   December 2007  ·   November 2007  ·   Octber 2007  ·   September 2007  ·   August 2007  ·   July 2007  ·   June 2007  ·   May 2007  ·   April 2007  ·   March 2007  ·   February 2007  ·   January 2007  ·   December 2006  ·   November 2006  ·   Octber 2006  ·   September 2006  ·   August 2006  ·   July 2006  ·   June 2006  ·   May 2006  ·   April 2006  ·   March 2006
Creative Commons License
This website is licensed under
a Creative Commons License.
Geeks of Doom is proudly powered by WordPress.

Students of the Unusual™ comic cover used with permission of 3BoysProductions
The Mercuri Bros.™ comic cover used with permission of Prodigal Son Press

Geeks of Doom is designed and maintained by our geeky webmaster
All original content copyright ©2005-2014 Geeks of Doom
All external content copyright of its respective owner, except where noted

Privacy Policy | Contact